| Cookies, gluten-free, chocolate wafer | 41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, MARSHMALLOW MATEYS | 40.9 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookies, marshmallow, with rice cereal and chocolate chips | 40.9 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, marshmallow, with rice cereal and chocolate chips | 40.9 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Peppers, sweet, red, freeze-dried | 40.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookies, chocolate sandwich, with creme filling, regular | 40.7 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, chocolate sandwich | 40.7 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookie, chocolate and vanilla sandwich | 40.7 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cake or cupcake, coconut | 40.6 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Beverages, ABBOTT, EAS soy protein powder | 40.5 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Nutritional powder mix (EAS Soy Protein Powder) | 40.5 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookies, sugar, refrigerated dough, baked | 40.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, HERSHEY, REESESTICKS crispy wafers, peanut butter, milk chocolate | 40.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, crispy bar with peanut butter filling | 40.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, HERSHEYS, PAYDAY Bar | 40.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookies, chocolate, made with rice cereal | 40.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, chocolate, made with rice cereal | 40.3 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, REESE'S NUTRAGEOUS Candy Bar | 40.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake or cupcake, chocolate with white icing, bakery | 40.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cake or cupcake, red velvet | 40.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Frostings, coconut-nut, ready-to-eat | 40 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Continental Mills, Krusteaz Almond Poppyseed Muffin Mix, Artificially Flavored, dry | 40 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snacks, granola bar, GENERAL MILLS, NATURE VALLEY, with yogurt coating | 40 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake, chocolate, commercially prepared with chocolate frosting, in-store bakery | 40 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereal or granola bar, with yogurt coating (General Mills Nature Valley Chewy Granola Bar) | 40 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookies, chocolate chip, commercially prepared, special dietary | 39.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, chocolate chip, reduced sugar | 39.8 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, TWIZZLERS Strawberry Twists Candy | 39.6 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Archway Home Style Cookies, Oatmeal Raisin | 39.6 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake or cupcake, banana | 39.6 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cake, pudding-type, chocolate, dry mix | 39.5 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake or cupcake, NFS | 39.5 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cake or cupcake, apple | 39.5 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookies, vanilla sandwich with creme filling | 39.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, Frosted Flakes | 39.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Infant formula, NESTLE, GOOD START SUPREME, with iron, powder | 39.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake or cupcake, white with white icing, from mix | 39.3 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookie, sandwich-type, not chocolate or vanilla | 39.3 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookie, vanilla sandwich | 39.3 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Graham crackers, sandwich, with filling | 39.3 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, MARS SNACKFOOD US, COCOAVIA Chocolate Bar | 39.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snacks, candy rolls, yogurt-covered, fruit flavored with high vitamin C | 39.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake, yellow, commercially prepared, with chocolate frosting, in-store bakery | 39.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereal, rice crispy, flavored | 39.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Prune puree | 39 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, MARS SNACKFOOD US, COCOAVIA Blueberry and Almond Chocolate Bar | 39 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beverage, instant breakfast powder, chocolate, sugar-free, not reconstituted | 39 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Nutritional powder mix, sugar free (Carnation Instant Breakfast) | 39 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Snacks, pretzels, hard, confectioner's coating, chocolate-flavor | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Tamarinds, raw | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Maraschino cherries, canned, drained | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Apple juice, frozen concentrate, unsweetened, undiluted, with added ascorbic acid | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snacks, M&M MARS, KUDOS Whole Grain Bar, chocolate chip | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Carrot, dehydrated | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snack, Pretzel, hard chocolate coated | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Apple juice, frozen concentrate, unsweetened, undiluted, without added ascorbic acid | 38.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake or cupcake, white with chocolate icing, bakery | 38.8 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pretzels, hard, coated, NFS | 38.8 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pretzels, hard, chocolate coated | 38.8 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cherries, maraschino | 38.8 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |