| Chocolate candy, coconut filled | 44.1 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Sage Valley, Gluten Free Vanilla Sandwich Cookies | 43.9 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, milk chocolate, with almonds | 43.9 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Tomato powder | 43.9 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, graham cracker with chocolate and marshmallow | 43.9 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, CAP'N CRUNCH'S Halloween Crunch | 43.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, chocolate-flavored frosted puffed corn | 43.7 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pineapple juice, frozen concentrate, unsweetened, undiluted | 43.6 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Nabisco, Nabisco Snackwell's Fat Free Devil's Food Cookie Cakes | 43.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Jams and preserves, apricot | 43.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, SWEET CRUNCH/QUISP | 43.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake, yellow, enriched, dry mix | 43.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Nuts, coconut meat, dried (desiccated), sweetened, shredded | 43.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, HONEY GRAHAM OH!S | 43.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, Cocoa DYNO-BITES | 43.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, MOTHER'S COCOA BUMPERS | 43.1 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, NESTLE, GOOBERS Chocolate Covered Peanuts | 43 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookies, sugar wafers with creme filling, regular | 43 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, sugar wafer | 43 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Puddings, chocolate, dry mix, regular | 42.9 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snacks, granola bar, GENERAL MILLS, NATURE VALLEY, CHEWY TRAIL MIX | 42.9 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereal or granola bar (General Mills Nature Valley Chewy Trail Mix) | 42.9 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cereal, crunch | 42.8 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Chutney | 42.7 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, Fruity DYNO-BITES | 42.6 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candy, nougat with nuts | 42.6 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, dark chocolate coated coffee beans | 42.5 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cranberry juice cocktail, frozen concentrate | 42.5 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, COLOSSAL CRUNCH | 42.5 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Glutino, Gluten Free Wafers, Lemon Flavored | 42.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookies, gluten-free, lemon wafer | 42.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snacks, granola bar, KASHI GOLEAN, chewy, mixed flavors | 42.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereal or granola bar (Kashi Chewy) | 42.3 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, peanut bar | 42.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake or cupcake, spice | 42.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Chocolate candy with nuts, other, NFS | 42.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Chocolate candy with nuts | 42.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookie, lemon bar | 42.1 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Syrups, table blends, pancake, with 2% maple | 42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Jams, preserves, marmalades, sweetened with fruit juice | 42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Babyfood, fortified cereal bar, fruit filling | 42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake, jelly roll | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Baby Toddler bar | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Syrup, NFS | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pancake syrup | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Jam or jelly, fruit juice sweetened | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cake, yellow, commercially prepared, with vanilla frosting | 41.8 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Peaches, dried, sulfured, uncooked | 41.7 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, BERRY COLOSSAL CRUNCH | 41.7 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Peach, dried | 41.7 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Alcoholic beverage, creme de menthe, 72 proof | 41.6 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, chocolate covered, caramel with nuts | 41.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake or cupcake, white with white icing, bakery | 41.3 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookies, chocolate sandwich, with creme filling, reduced fat | 41.2 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, chocolate chip, made from home recipe or purchased at a bakery | 41.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookie, chocolate sandwich, reduced fat | 41.2 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Peppers, hot chile, sun-dried | 41.1 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookies, animal, with frosting or icing | 41.1 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, animal, with frosting or icing | 41.1 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Glutino, Gluten Free Wafers, Milk Chocolate | 41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |