| Candy, NFS | 51 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Beverages, Chocolate-flavored drink, whey and milk based | 50 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Chocolate milk drink | 50 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Nutrition bar or meal replacement bar, NFS | 50 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Fast foods, sundae, hot fudge | 49 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Mole sauce | 49 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, HERSHEY, REESESTICKS crispy wafers, peanut butter, milk chocolate | 48 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, crispy bar with peanut butter filling | 48 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Light ice cream bar, chocolate | 48 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Waffle, chocolate | 48 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Snack, BALANCE, original bar | 47 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Ice cream cookie sandwich | 47 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Nutrition bar (Balance Original Bar) | 47 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Topping, SMUCKER'S MAGIC SHELL | 46 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pudding, chocolate, made from dry mix | 46 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Waffle, chocolate, fast food / restaurant | 46 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Desserts, mousse, chocolate, prepared-from-recipe | 45 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, NESTLE, OH HENRY! Bar | 44 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beverages, Cocoa mix, powder, prepared with water | 44 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Mousse | 44 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Light Ice Cream, soft serve, blended with cookie pieces | 43 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Ice cream sandwich, made with light ice cream, vanilla | 43 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Ice cream sandwich, vanilla, light, no sugar added | 43 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, dry mix, made with water | 43 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, dry mix, made with whole or reduced fat (2%) milk | 43 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, dry mix, made with lowfat (1%) or fat free (skim) milk | 43 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, dry mix , made with non-dairy milk | 43 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cake or cupcake, NFS | 43 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Snacks, granola bars, soft, coated, milk chocolate coating, peanut butter | 42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Rennin, chocolate, dry mix, prepared with 2% milk | 42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Rennin, chocolate, dry mix, prepared with whole milk | 42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Ice cream cookie sandwich | 42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, dry mix, made with water, with whipped cream | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Light ice cream cone, chocolate, prepackaged | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cereal or granola bar, coated with non-chocolate coating | 42 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Granola bar, soft, milk chocolate coated, peanut butter | 41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snacks, granola bar, with coconut, chocolate coated | 41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Ice cream bar, covered with chocolate and nuts | 41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Frozen yogurt, soft serve, chocolate | 41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Milk shake, fast food, chocolate | 41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Milk shake, bottled, chocolate | 41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Crepe, chocolate filled | 41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cereal or granola bar, with coconut, chocolate coated | 41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cereal or granola bar with nuts, chocolate coated | 41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pancakes, chocolate | 41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Beverages, tea, instant, lemon, unsweetened | 40 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Peanut butter and chocolate spread | 40 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pancakes, chocolate, fast food / restaurant | 40 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Puddings, chocolate, dry mix, instant, prepared with 2% milk | 39 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cream puff, eclair, custard or cream filled, iced, reduced fat | 39 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candy, caramel | 38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Nutritional drink or shake, ready-to-drink (Carnation Instant Breakfast) | 38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, NFS | 37 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Light ice cream, chocolate | 37 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, NESTLE, BUTTERFINGER Bar | 36 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, Cocoa DYNO-BITES | 36 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, reduced sugar, made with non-dairy milk | 36 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, reduced sugar, made with whole or reduced fat (2%) milk | 36 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, reduced sugar, made with lowfat (1%) or fat free (skim) milk | 36 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pudding, chocolate, made from dry mix, sugar free | 36 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |