| Chocolate candy, cookie filled | 4.7 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Oil or table fat, NFS | 4.69 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cookie, with peanut butter filling, chocolate-coated | 4.68 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, square-cut shoulder chops, separable lean and fat, raw | 4.68 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookie, with peanut butter filling, chocolate-coated | 4.68 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Beef, rib, back ribs, bone-in, separable lean and fat, trimmed to 0" fat, all grades, cooked, braised | 4.66 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, frozen, loin, separable lean and fat, cooked, broiled | 4.65 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, MARS SNACKFOOD US, TWIX Caramel Cookie Bars | 4.59 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Dessert topping, semi solid, frozen | 4.58 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pate de foie gras, canned (goose liver pate), smoked | 4.58 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pate, goose liver, smoked, canned | 4.58 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Whipped topping | 4.58 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, frozen, composite of trimmed retail cuts, separable lean and fat, raw | 4.56 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef, rib, shortribs, separable lean and fat, choice, raw | 4.54 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef, rib, back ribs, bone-in, separable lean and fat, trimmed to 0" fat, all grades, raw | 4.54 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Oil, sunflower, linoleic, (approx. 65%) | 4.5 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Lamb, Australian, imported, fresh, rib chop, frenched, bone-in, separable lean and fat, trimmed to 1/8" fat, cooked, grilled | 4.5 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Puff pastry, frozen, ready-to-bake | 4.49 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef, cured, breakfast strips, cooked | 4.48 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef, bacon, cooked | 4.48 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Margarine-like, vegetable oil-butter spread, reduced calorie, tub, with salt | 4.44 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Oil, soybean, salad or cooking | 4.44 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, frozen, loin, separable lean and fat, trimmed to 1/8" fat, raw | 4.43 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, neck chops, separable lean and fat, cooked, braised | 4.43 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pork, cured, bacon, cooked, baked | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Blood sausage | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Blood sausage | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Popcorn, NFS | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Popcorn, microwave, NFS | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Popcorn, microwave, plain | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Popcorn, microwave, butter flavored | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Candies, milk chocolate coated raisins | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Oil, tomatoseed | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Chocolate candy with dried fruit | 4.4 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Popcorn, microwave, cheese flavored | 4.39 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Oil, industrial, soy (partially hydrogenated ) and soy (winterized), pourable clear fry | 4.35 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Oscar Mayer, Bologna (beef) | 4.34 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Oil, sunflower, high oleic (70% and over) | 4.32 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, frozen, shoulder, whole (arm and blade), separable lean and fat, trimmed to 1/8" fat, cooked, braised | 4.32 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Sour dressing, non-butterfat, cultured, filled cream-type | 4.31 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Oil, industrial, soy, low linolenic | 4.31 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Seeds, watermelon seed kernels, dried | 4.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Oil, palm | 4.3 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pork, cured, bacon, cooked, broiled, pan-fried or roasted, reduced sodium | 4.29 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cream substitute, powdered | 4.29 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Coffee creamer, powder | 4.29 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Coffee creamer,powder, sugar free, flavored | 4.29 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Beef, bacon, reduced sodium, cooked | 4.29 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pork bacon, NS as to fresh, smoked or cured, reduced sodium, cooked | 4.29 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pork bacon, smoked or cured, reduced sodium, cooked | 4.29 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, netted shoulder, rolled, boneless, separable lean and fat, cooked, slow roasted | 4.28 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pork, cured, breakfast strips, raw or unheated | 4.27 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Lamb, New Zealand, imported, frozen, composite of trimmed retail cuts, separable lean and fat, cooked | 4.27 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef, rib, large end (ribs 6-9), separable lean and fat, trimmed to 1/8" fat, prime, cooked, broiled | 4.26 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cookies, chocolate chip, prepared from recipe, made with butter | 4.26 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cocoa, dry powder, unsweetened | 4.25 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef, rib, back ribs, bone-in, separable lean and fat, trimmed to 0" fat, select, cooked, braised | 4.25 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cocoa powder, not reconstituted | 4.25 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Fish oil, salmon | 4.24 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef, rib, small end (ribs 10-12), separable lean and fat, trimmed to 1/8" fat, prime, cooked, roasted | 4.23 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |