| Snacks, M&M MARS, KUDOS Whole Grain Bar, chocolate chip | 4.47 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Peas, green (includes baby and lesuer types), canned, drained solids, unprepared | 4.47 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Doughnut, cake type, chocolate icing | 4.47 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Potato pancake | 4.47 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Green peas, canned, cooked, no added fat | 4.47 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, MALT-O-MEAL, HONEY GRAHAM SQUARES | 4.46 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Nachos, cheese only | 4.46 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Pasta with vegetables, no sauce or dressing | 4.46 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Macaroni or pasta salad, made with mayonnaise | 4.46 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cinnamon buns, frosted (includes honey buns) | 4.45 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Soup, vegetable beef, canned, condensed | 4.45 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, CAP'N CRUNCH with CRUNCHBERRIES | 4.45 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Roll, sweet, cinnamon bun, frosted | 4.45 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Roll, sweet, with fruit, frosted, diet | 4.45 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Potato, baked, peel not eaten, with chili | 4.45 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Baking chocolate, MARS SNACKFOOD US, M&M's Semisweet Chocolate Mini Baking Bits | 4.44 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, Christmas Crunch | 4.44 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Peas, green, canned, no salt added, drained solids | 4.42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Corn pudding, home prepared | 4.42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Soup, chicken broth, canned, condensed | 4.42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Martha White Foods, Martha White's Chewy Fudge Brownie Mix, dry | 4.42 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cream puff, eclair, custard or cream filled, iced | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Milk dessert bar, frozen, made from lowfat milk | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Archway Home Style Cookies, Frosty Lemon | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Beef stew, canned entree | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Fat free ice cream, no sugar added, flavors other than chocolate | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, CAP'N CRUNCH'S Halloween Crunch | 4.41 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Hot chocolate / cocoa, dry mix, reduced sugar, made with lowfat (1%) or fat free (skim) milk | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Ice cream bar, chocolate | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Cream puff, eclair, custard or cream filled, iced | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Potato, mashed, from fresh, made with milk, with cheese | 4.41 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Breakfast bar, corn flake crust with fruit | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Heinz, Weight Watcher, Chocolate Eclair, frozen | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Frozen yogurts, chocolate, nonfat milk, sweetened without sugar | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Frozen novelties, ice cream type, chocolate or caramel covered, with nuts | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Snacks, FARLEY CANDY, FARLEY Fruit Snacks, with vitamins A, C, and E | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Quinoa, cooked | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, NESTLE, RAISINETS Chocolate Covered Raisins | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Yogurt, fruit variety, nonfat | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Nutritional supplement for people with diabetes, liquid | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake, white, prepared from recipe with coconut frosting | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake, gingerbread, dry mix | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Pie, banana cream, prepared from recipe | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Yogurt, fruit variety, nonfat, fortified with vitamin D | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Yogurt, frozen, flavors not chocolate, nonfat milk, with low-calorie sweetener | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cake, yellow, unenriched, dry mix | 4.4 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Ice cream candy bar | 4.4 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Breakfast bar, NFS | 4.4 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Breakfast bar, cereal crust with fruit filling, lowfat | 4.4 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Nutritional drink or shake, ready-to-drink, sugar free (Glucerna) | 4.4 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Potatoes, microwaved, cooked in skin, skin, without salt | 4.39 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Potatoes, microwaved, cooked, in skin, skin with salt | 4.39 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Cereals ready-to-eat, QUAKER, CAP'N CRUNCH | 4.39 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Candies, fudge, chocolate, with nuts, prepared-from-recipe | 4.38 | SR Legacy · April 2018 (historical final) |
| Light ice cream, NFS | 4.38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Light ice cream, vanilla | 4.38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Baked beans from fast food / restaurant | 4.38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Sopaipilla with syrup or honey | 4.38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Quinoa, no added fat | 4.38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |
| Macaroni or pasta salad, made with mayonnaise-type salad dressing | 4.38 | Survey (FNDDS) · 2021–2023 |